“Deliberately shutting down the Super Bowl halftime show. Let’s come together and show big corporations that they can’t do whatever they want without consequences (which equals their ratings). You are in their interest. Realize you have the power. Shut down this halftime show. A show of fake American citizens openly hating America. I can’t stand for this.”

Serrano, a multi-division title holder who has long been positioned as a central figure in Paul’s promotion structure, responded with a cautious statement that comes across in a sport built on loyalty between boxer and promoter.

“Puerto Ricans are not ‘fake Americans.’ We are citizens who have contributed to this country in everything from military service to sports, business, science and the arts, and our identity and citizenship deserve respect.”

Serrano’s public break puts promoter-fighter alliance under pressure ahead of future negotiations and event positioning

Tonight I am where I am supposed to be on my beautiful island, celebrating with my people and watching in awe how well Benito represents us and our culture

I am proud to be Puerto Rican and proud to be an American citizen. Puerto Ricans are not “fake Americans.” us…

— Amanda Serrano (@Serranosisters) February 9, 2026

Her response was met with backlash in a sport built on loyalty between boxers and promoters, especially when major funding and venue costs often depend on local support. Serrano acknowledges the opportunities she’s been given while drawing firm boundaries around her identity.

“I do not agree with statements that question the legitimacy or identity of the Puerto Rican people and I cannot support that characterization. It is wrong.”

The reaction rippled through the combat circuit. Logan Paul also weighed in.

Jake Paul does live in Puerto Rico, even 😐 https://t.co/kH5tS5RIfa

– 0 (@rdgrlt) February 9, 2026

“I love my brother, but I don’t agree with this. Puerto Ricans are Americans, and I’m glad they get a chance to showcase the talent that comes from the island.”

Promoters rarely welcome headlines that have nothing to do with matchmaking or wallets. Reputation often affects sanctioning relationships, site access, and municipal support more quickly than outcomes within circles.

Paul made Puerto Rico a base of residence and business while aligning himself with champions who attracted strong gates on the island.